Besman did not even expect Hooker to perform
the blues — not by any traditional definition of blues music. Instead, he let
the guitarist riff on a single chord while improvising a narrative. These
weren’t even songs, just freewheeling grooves, without a clear beginning,
middle, or end. They concluded after around three minutes each, but that was
imposed by the limitations of a 78rpm record. Directing Hooker in the studio
was not like producing other acts. Most bands arrive at a session prepared to
play well-rehearsed material which they refine into polished, finished
performances. Not so for Hooker: a second take would produce, likely as not, a
substantially different song. Methodical production would never have worked for
the young John Lee Hooker. He would have covered the whole history of the blues
in twenty takes, and be no closer to a definitive version of a specific song. Besman
didn’t want polished performances; he wanted to capture the heat of the moment.
He went with the flow, and if take two sounded like a different song, Besman
simply assigned it a separate title.

Thanks for this. Have you ever read Robert Palmer's DEEP BLUES? I still keep hoping that one will turn up in an ebook format, but no luck so far...
ReplyDeleteHi Durktle,
DeleteI don't have the Palmer book, there's a Harry Smith website at harrysmusic dot wordpress dot com that has a chapter scanned as pdf if you click on "readings" in the right hand column.
A copy of the book has been scanned by the internet archive - archive dot org & search for "Robert Palmer Deep Blues - but is unavailable. There is a huge amount of interesting stuff they've scanned that likewise comes up "item not available" when you click on the link - If anybody knows how to access these files that would be hugely appreciated.
all the best,
Johnny
Thanks for the info. That's still one of the best books about blues music that I've ever read. The documentary is pretty amazing too...turned me onto Burnside, Kimbrough, and a lot of others. The Internet Archive's copy must have been one of the many they had up and available before they started paying attention to copyright restrictions...pffbt.
ReplyDeleteI click download, but nothing happens... :(
ReplyDeleteAndrey,
ReplyDeleteI've just put new links in the main post.
all the best,
Johnny